Article China cold war democratization expansionism Featured Item Finance foreign policy Historical memory Separatism Show on Homepage taiwan

The Island the Left Neglected

The Island the Left Neglected

The Island the Left Neglected

If the American left is critical about opposing a reactionary overseas coverage that preserves unequal energy relations, it ought to converse up for Taiwan.

Jeffrey C. H. Ngo ▪ Fall 2018
Taiwanese president Tsai Ing-Wen talking in August 2018 (Presidential Palace of the Republic of China / Flickr)

Think about a small, peaceable, progressive island in Asia about the measurement of Maryland. Dominated till the Chilly Warfare’s very finish by a army dictatorship, it’s now a strong democracy, though it endures incessant hostility from its big neighbor. Its individuals treasure their hard-fought equality, free press, and vibrant civil society.

Forty-three out of its 113 lawmakers are feminine, which, in proportion, is nearly double that of the U.S. Congress. With a contemporary, environment friendly single-payer healthcare system like Canada’s, it offers complete insurance coverage protection for each citizen at the value of simply round 6.2 % of its GDP per yr. A invoice granting aboriginal languages official standing was handed in Might 2017 as a part of a wider endeavor to uphold the rights of its indigenous communities after they acquired a proper authorities apology earlier for hundreds of years of “pain and mistreatment.” The landmark decree by its highest courtroom that very same month is paving the method for it to turn into the continent’s first nation to legalize same-sex marriage. It’s also striving to satisfy an formidable objective to part out nuclear energy by 2025 and be sure that one-fifth of its complete power output is renewable.

Its sixty-two-year-old chief, Tsai Ing-wen, is a lady with no kinship or marriage ties to a political dynasty, in contrast to any of her Asian counterparts earlier than her. A former professor of worldwide regulation, she made her debut in public service in the 1990s as a commerce negotiator, earlier than working her personal method up in the male-dominated world of politics, serving as a cupboard member, lawmaker, vice premier, Democratic Progressive Celebration (DPP) chairwoman, and now president. She swept to a landslide victory in January 2016 by gaining 56.1 % of all ballots forged in a three-way race. Her pan-Inexperienced coalition—a broad alliance consisting of teams that favor a larger diploma of democracy and self-determination—concurrently gained a majority in the parliament, referred to as the Legislative Yuan, for the very first time.

In fact, the nation is actual; it’s Taiwan.

Many People could also be unfamiliar with it, which is a consequence of its isolation on the international stage. It’s barred from belonging to the UN and dozens of different intergovernmental organizations. As of this fall, solely seventeen nations—down from twenty simply months earlier—acknowledge it in any respect. None have diplomatic relations with Beijing.


Boasting the world’s largest standing military and an expansionist outlook, the Individuals’s Republic of China deems Taiwan a “renegade province” that have to be “reunified” sooner or later. And since the Chinese language declare the island as a part of their territory, they exit of their approach to block its worldwide participation. Primarily, they’ve made befriending Taiwan a zero-sum recreation for anybody who dares to take action, and the guidelines are easy: Interact with us and we’ll reward you; interact with them and we’ll punish you. It’s fierce greenback diplomacy Beijing insists on waging, and Taipei can’t win.

Understandably, Taiwanese individuals, particularly the progressive youth, have grown more and more unenthusiastic about China. In a current ballot that requested whether or not unification is an choice if China democratizes (itself an extended shot), simply 24 % of respondents aged thirty-nine or under stated sure, whereas 73 % stated no. Since 2009, based on one other survey, a majority of the island’s inhabitants has persistently self-identified as Taiwanese—not as Chinese language, nor as each—an indication that they’ve lengthy assumed their de facto independence. As Xi Jinping continues to rule China with an iron fist and as Taiwan marches ahead, the hole throughout the strait will solely widen.

Simply how devoted the island’s new era is to a homeland freed from Chinese language interference was on full show when the Sunflower Motion broke out in the spring of 2014, throughout which scholar activists stormed the Legislative Yuan chamber and would stay there for 24 days. Their demand? To withdraw the Cross-Strait Service Commerce Settlement, which, initiated by then-President Ma Ying-jeou, would have pitted small Taiwanese companies towards state-owned Chinese language enterprises. Half one million individuals took to the streets of Taipei in solidarity with the sit-in that drew inspiration from Occupy Wall Road. The DPP was likewise sympathetic. Collectively the united opposition prompted the deal’s indefinite postponement. Two years later, Tsai dropped all felony expenses towards the protesters following her inauguration as Ma’s successor.

As a various, tolerant nation with a pacesetter who has shattered the final glass ceiling for Asian ladies, there’s each cause to anticipate that Taiwan’s most trustworthy allies in the U.S. are on the left. Besides that isn’t the case in any respect: American progressives are likely to view it as both a reactionary state or one among no significance.


On December 2, 2016, Donald Trump made historical past when he accepted President Tsai’s temporary congratulations on his election victory over the telephone. It was not more than a “courtesy call,” Mike Pence stated. A number of outstanding Congressional Republicans, together with Home Speaker Paul Ryan and Senator Tom Cotton, thought it was a terrific concept. John Bolton, who would later grow to be Trump’s nationwide safety advisor, electrified conservatives when he declared on Fox & Buddies: “Nobody in Beijing gets to dictate who we talk to.”

However then got here the partisan backlash. It simply so completely match the anti-Trump narrative: a buffoon elected president who was already, earlier than taking workplace, eroding well-established “norms” as a result of he was both too reckless or too ignorant. “That’s how wars start,” tweeted Senator Chris Murphy. Trump’s “flippant calls” have been “threatening to create diplomatic crises,” Vainness Truthful asserted in the similar article that in contrast Tsai with different controversial world leaders with whom Trump had additionally spoken, like Rodrigo Duterte of the Philippines and Nursultan Nazarbayev of Kazakhstan, as if she, too, was a infamous human rights abuser. Ned Worth, a spokesman for Barack Obama, rushed to reiterate the discriminatory “One China” coverage—designed by Henry Kissinger in 1972—in the identify of “peaceful and stable cross-Strait relations.”

Most U.S. front-page headlines described the dialog negatively, portraying it not as a chance to bolster the United States’ ties with Taiwan however as an unprovoked violation of Chinese language sovereignty. The false notion of Tsai as a Trump sidekick intent on throwing East Asia into disarray was widespread. Trevor Noah, on his Every day Present, mocked her English accent and ridiculed her as an Uber driver “in the Camry” too insignificant for Trump. Even critical progressives concentrated simply on the risks of approaching Tsai, a supposed “blunder of potentially historic proportions,” as Vox put it, that solely foreign-policy amateurs like Trump might make.

Absent from the mainstream media discourse have been the views of abnormal Taiwanese, most of whom don’t remotely share Trump’s politics however have been delighted to study of their nation’s lengthy overdue acceptance and validation on the worldwide stage. One commentator referred to as it “the happiest thing” for Taiwan since the Jimmy Carter years.

For Lin Fei-fan, a former Sunflower scholar chief, the put-downs of Taiwan and its chief have been tremendously irritating; how might the similar People who would in any other case advocate the core values his nation epitomized deride it this manner? The “anxious reaction” was simply an try “to score political points against Trump,” he and two fellow youth activists argued in the Washington Publish. “We are puzzled why many commentators have treated Trump’s move as an ‘affront’ to authoritarian China rather than consider the possibility of normalizing relations with a democratic nation of 23 million people, many of whom share deep affinities with the United States,” they added. “Despite having the world’s 21st-largest GDP and a larger population than that of Australia, our flourishing multicultural society is internationally silenced and played as a pawn of superpower politics.”

If it sounds peculiar that supporting arguably the most progressive Asian nation is an agenda so affiliated with American conservatism, it’s as a result of the left has but to elude the shadows of the Chilly Conflict.


When China embraced communism in 1949, the defeated Kuomintang (KMT)—underneath the repressive rule of Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek and, later, his son Chiang Ching-kuo—retreated to Taiwan. It was deeply suspicious of its home critics, like far-right regimes elsewhere, and it was all the time planning to satisfy its hopeless fantasy to complete the unfinished Chinese language Civil Struggle. Beijing, too, by no means ceased eager to seize Taiwan. So, as late as the waning days of 1986, this was the state of affairs Washington confronted: neither aspect might settle for coexistence as they every claimed to be the sole, rightful proprietor of China and Taiwan mixed. To maintain playing on Beijing—which first started with Richard Nixon’s well-known go to in 1972 and formalized when Carter severed diplomatic ties in 1979 with Taipei—appeared smart sufficient.

It was under no circumstances conceivable that Taiwan can be the one to emerge as Asia’s beacon of freedom so quickly whereas China would backslide.

However by 1989, the youthful Chiang was lifeless, the island’s thirty-eight-year-old martial regulation was gone, and Lee Teng-hui, a one-of-a-kind transformative determine, was in agency management. The new chief swiftly did away with the ridiculous fangong dalu (“counterattack the mainland”) motto for good and decriminalized opposition events, which facilitated the DPP’s first electoral good points. After the Tiananmen Bloodbath, on the different hand, George H. W. Bush made an early decision towards sanctioning the Chinese language, which aggrandized the unfastened however rising group of pro-Taipei neocons that may come to be generally known as the Blue Group (in distinction to Pink China). American ties with Beijing then elevated dramatically beneath Invoice Clinton, who was, at greatest, lukewarm about Taiwan.

Nonetheless, the island defied all odds and stored progressing. For eight months in the run-up to its first-ever direct presidential election in March 1996—a legacy of the 1990 Wild Lily Motion and the Lee administration’s subsequent reforms—the Chinese language army carried out a collection of aggravating missile exams aimed toward portray Lee as a warmonger and intimidating the citizens into voting towards him. It backfired. Two American warships arrived at the final minute to avert a possible escalation, and he handily gained the race that reworked him from Taiwan’s final authoritarian chief to its first popularly elected one. Democratization was accomplished 4 years later, in 2000, when DPP presidential candidate Chen Shui-bian’s exceptional victory—because of a historic voter turnout price of 82.7 %—facilitated the KMT’s peaceable concession of energy.

Concurrently in Washington, the Blue Workforce turned ever extra influential with Congress, assume tanks, and even the incoming president’s internal circle. However whereas George W. Bush and his neoconservative allies have been eager to confront Beijing early in his first time period, they quickly discovered themselves needing essential Chinese language cooperation in North Korea and particularly the Center East after 9/11; this compelled Bush to talk out towards Taiwanese independence in December 2003. The “One China” coverage therefore survived as a cornerstone of American overseas coverage. Obama’s “pivot to Asia” didn’t alter that both, as he stored Taiwan out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership negotiations, though the free-trade pact was itself designed to counterbalance China’s regional clout.


Right now in Trump’s America, the staunchest supporters of Taiwan have been the similar band of Republican hawks, from heavyweights akin to Bob Dole and the late John McCain to Senators Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz, who’re descendants of the Blue Group. Due to this interconnection, the challenge continues to be perceived as a right-wing trigger with which progressives are reluctant to be related. But the vicious cycle needn’t proceed: Taiwan is now Inexperienced, not Blue.

Actually, most Taiwanese not regard Chiang Kai-shek as an honorable commander who misplaced the Civil Struggle however as a ruthless tyrant who, for some three many years throughout the interval often known as White Terror, tortured, imprisoned, and murdered tens of hundreds of dissidents. In February 2000, the metropolis of Taoyuan accomplished development of the Cihu Memorial Sculpture Park, the place over 200 torn-down Chiang statues from throughout the nation have since been collected and rebuilt, proper subsequent to the former KMT headman’s mausoleum. This was removed from sufficient, so the Legislative Yuan handed a sweeping transitional-justice invoice final yr requiring the removing of all remaining commemorative symbols of Chiang from faculties, establishments, and public areas.

The rejection of Chiang’s reminiscence displays an plain actuality: the previous assumption that each Taiwan and China lengthy to unite as one nation-state however disagree on which regime has legitimacy is just not correct anymore. Beijing’s failure to uphold the promise of autonomy in Hong Kong and Macau solely makes unification with Taiwan much more far-fetched. For People nowadays to nonetheless defend Kissinger’s “One China” coverage—a shameful, self-serving misinform please the Chinese language—is to fake in any other case; the passive technique goals to do the naked minimal to take care of the established order, a established order that’s inherently unjust.

It’s excessive time for the political left to rethink Taiwan. Progressives’ silence—whether or not as a result of they’re oblivious to the island’s altering political panorama or disinclined to anger Beijing—does a grave disservice to the Taiwanese individuals who have come such a great distance.


They usually nonetheless have an extended solution to go.

Taiwan’s egalitarian democracy is fragile. Having moved away from the Chiang household’s extremism, the KMT stays certainly one of the two main political events, at present with thirty-five seats in the Legislative Yuan. Ought to the traditionalist pan-Blue coalition—which clings to the anachronistic conception of “Greater China” and runs on a platform of restoring the cross-strait consanguinity—return to energy in the future, it might reverse a lot of the island’s current progress. Its ageing, shrinking, however energetic base of help additionally varieties a strong pressure resisting efforts to formally ditch Taiwan’s out of date identify: the Republic of China. In the meantime, the forward-looking DPP has different inner obstacles to beat. Taiwan’s wages are modest for a developed financial system, for example, and virtually 90 % of the inhabitants oppose abolishing the demise penalty, which is widespread in Asia.

However the place the island struggles most has all the time been on the world stage. When the SARS epidemic was killing a whole lot of victims in neighboring Hong Kong and China again in 2003, Taiwanese epidemiologists needed to fight the illness alone after the WHO denied them entry to samples and knowledge. Few issues have modified over the years. The Worldwide Olympic Committee returned a verdict this Might that pressured Staff Taiwan to maintain enjoying underneath the awkward “Chinese Taipei” designation in the forthcoming Tokyo 2020 Video games. Even with the deck stacked towards it, nevertheless, Taiwan has not stopped preventing for respect and recognition.

The island deserves them; it has by no means exploited its diplomatic alienation to behave out. Fairly, it has confirmed again and again to be a accountable, if minor, energy. At a time when many Western nations are turning inward, Tsai has referred to as immigrants “an infusion of new strength and a force for cultural diversity.” Her administration can also be backing numerous nonprofit teams, along with spearheading its personal initiatives, to supply refugees throughout the globe—in Iraq, Jordan, Thailand, Nauru, and Italy—Taiwanese financial and medical help.

Individually, Reporters With out Borders determined final yr towards opening a brand new Asian bureau in Hong Kong—which has misplaced its popularity as a bastion of free speech beneath heavy-handed Chinese language jurisdiction—and picked Taipei as an alternative. In line with the group’s 2018 World Press Freedom Index, Taiwan ranks the highest in Asia (and even larger than the U.S.), whereas China is positioned, together with Syria and North Korea, in the backside 5 globally.

If the American left is critical about opposing a reactionary overseas coverage that preserves unequal energy relations, it ought to converse up for Taiwan. Its enlightened views on gender, ethnicity, and sophistication have translated right into a social construction that’s reminiscent, in sure methods, of Northern Europe’s. Its functionality and readiness to deal with the biggest challenges of our time, from terrorism to local weather change, make it a well-deserved member of the worldwide group. Its unlikely historic trajectory exhibits that bringing real progress to part of the world the place particular person liberties are extra typically threatened than cherished is feasible.

Jeffrey C. H. Ngo is an activist historian of and from Hong Kong. At present pursuing his PhD in Historical past at Georgetown College, he additionally serves as chief researcher for Demosisto, the Hong Kong-based youth political group that advocates self-determination. In 2017–18, he was a visiting scholar at the College of Toronto.

fbq(‘init’, ‘552845971584446’,
em: ‘insert_email_variable,’
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));